“Cyprus
is a key partner in a challenging region, (but) it can be an even stronger
partner if the next generation of Cypriots can grow up without the burden of
conflict,” said US Vice President Joe Biden on Thursday night before leaving
Cyprus, the Cyprus Mail reports.
Biden
ended his two-day visit to the island with rousing words despite the absence of
any concrete announcement on the much-hyped confidence-building measures
(CBMs).
“Cyprus
can be a growing force for peace, prosperity and stability in the eastern
Mediterranean. And that would benefit the world. That would benefit us all,” he
said.
Earlier
he led a US delegation including Amos Hochstein, deputy assistant secretary for
energy diplomacy, in a bilateral meeting with Anastasiades and his ministers of
finance, energy and foreign affairs, the undersecretary to the president,
government spokesman and Cypriot ambassador to Washington. The meeting lasted
almost an hour and a half and was followed by lunch.
In
the afternoon, Biden met with Turkish Cypriot leader Dervis Eroglu for an hour
in the north. Following their meeting, Eroglu told reporters the two discussed
the Cyprus problem, natural gas and confidence-building measures (CBMs) in
general. “The name Varosha did not come up,” he said.
After
spending some time with members of the business community and civil society
from both communities, Biden hosted a dinner for the two leaders and UN Special
Representative Lisa Buttenheim at Nicosia’s Chateau Status in the buffer zone.
Afterwards
Biden said he was “truly impressed by the cordiality and ease with which both
leaders speak to one another and negotiate with one another”. He said the two
shared common ground on certain aspects and differences on others, but not “irreconcilable”
differences. “There’s clearly a lot of work to be done but what I’m hearing
gives me hope that a solution is within reach this time.”
Biden
said that the two leaders had reaffirmed their full commitment to the joint
declaration, had agreed to speed up the process for a comprehensive settlement agreeing
to meet at least twice a month, and agreed to intensify work on preparing
meaningful CBMs.
“For
our part the US will engage with all stakeholders to explore mutually
beneficial initiatives to reinforce settlement negotiations,” he said. He added
that the US encourages the leaders to discuss a package on Varosha and
Famagusta and that “if the two sides were to agree on this, the US would stand
ready to assist on implementation.”
The
US also wants to see “quick and substantial progress” on core issues to lead
the talks to the final phase, though ultimately, he warned, “the solution
cannot come from outside” but from the two leaders and from the “compelling
voices” of civil society.
Earlier
in the day at the Presidential Palace, Biden highlighted in a toast that time
and circumstances have given Cyprus a significant role to play in the region.
“You
are emerging as a leader in the region and Cyprus is poised to become a key
player in the Eastern Mediterranean” transforming it into a new global hub for
natural gas and markets, he said, adding, “You are uniquely situated at a
critical time in modern history.” He repeated the position that Cyprus is a
“genuine strategic partner” of the US, cooperating on all the “biggest issues
of the day” including Syria’s chemical weapons, non-proliferation of nuclear
weapons and the Ukraine crisis.
“This
is not just a strategic partnership, it’s a growing partnership,” he said,
adding that the two countries could achieve even more with a Cyprus solution.
Varosha
demands were made ‘in bad faith’
Efforts
to clinch a deal during the US Vice President’s visit that would allow experts
to enter Varosha and study its condition collapsed because the Turkish Cypriot
leadership tried to “humiliate” the Greek Cypriots, with Ankara’s backing,
Foreign Minister Ioannis Kasoulides said.
According
to Kasoulides, a necessary first step for the return of Famagusta would be to
allow experts to enter the fenced area and study how infrastructure works could
begin, looking at electricity, water supply, sewage, roads, pavements etc. The
next phase would be to study whether the buildings are safe to live in so that
the legitimate residents of Varosha could eventually return to their properties.
Experts could also undertake studies to upgrade Famagusta port, he added.
“It
was not possible to agree by the Vice President’s visit due to certain demands
of the Turkish Cypriots which for us were not only unacceptable but also made
in bad faith. They wanted to humiliate us with the inclusion of a special
reference that these international experts could be foreign or Turkish Cypriot,
but explicitly not Greek Cypriot,” he said.
Kasoulides
said the Greek Cypriot side would have been happy to accept internationals only
or foreign experts assisted by both Greek and Turkish Cypriots working
together. “We never demanded that the experts be either Greek Cypriot or
Turkish Cypriot, but we cannot accept that Greek Cypriots are forbidden in an
area which is purely Greek,” he said.
Kasoulides
also expressed his disappointment with Ankara’s stance, saying that while
Turkish officials declare their willingness for a solution of the Cyprus
problem, at the same time, they do not put their words into practice.
Kasoulides
also insisted that relations with Russia have not been harmed in any way by the
enhanced Cyprus-US relations. “Russia respects Cyprus’ right to exercise its
foreign policy within the EU, where we belong.”
Government
spokesman Nicos Christodoulides confirmed that “intense negotiations” were held
in the last two weeks on Famagusta, with the US playing a leading role in
contacts with Ankara and the Turkish Cypriots. He said Biden tried very hard to
get something specific on Famagusta while here but it did not prove possible.
“The
US Vice President saw firsthand the stance of the Turkish side,” said
Christodoulides, adding it was important for the Americans to see which side
adopts a constructive stance, and who’s creating obstacles.
“We
got close to an agreement that would have allowed the gradual implementation of
the president’s proposal but the Turkish side’s stance was clear. The aim was
not to promote the measures, but other objectives that we were not prepared to
follow.”
A
choice between Russia and the US
An
editorial in the Cyprus Mail says the real significance of US Vice President
Joe Biden’s visit to Cyprus lie in Biden’s comments that Cyprus is a “genuine
strategic partner” of the US, that it “is emerging as a key partner in a
challenging region” and that it “is poised to become a key player in the
Eastern Mediterranean.” Secretary of State John Kerry also spoke about the
strategic partnership when he met Foreign Minister Ioannis Kasoulides in
Washington less than two weeks ago; he too is scheduled to visit Cyprus later
in the year.
Many
people, quite understandably, found it difficult, if not impossible, to take
these words seriously, wondering whether he was pulling our leg. Why on earth
would the superpower pay lip service to a partnership with a tiny and powerless
state with a collapsed economy that requires financial assistance from abroad
to stay afloat? It would appear that Cyprus has become central to the US plans
for the region which are directly linked to hydrocarbons and the new Cold War
between the West and Russia.
AKEL
chief Andros Kyprianou may have been repeating his party’s traditional
prejudices when he said the main concern of Biden’s visit was energy and the
Ukraine crisis, but he was right.
Energy
Minister Giorgos Lakkotrypis offered a plausible explanation of US plans. “The
Americans see Cyprus not only as an alternative supply source, but potentially
an alternative corridor of energy supply.” During the talks in Nicosia on
Thursday, the Americans discussed the need to reduce the EU’s energy dependence
on its traditional supplier, said Lakkotrypis, obviously referring to Russia.
Natural
gas deposits in the Eastern Mediterranean may be small by comparison to
Russia’s but the US still feels that by providing the EU with an “alternative
corridor of energy supply”, it could limit Moscow’s energy dominance in Europe.
But for the US energy plans for the region to succeed there must be a
settlement of the Cyprus problem so that the co-operation of all the countries
in the region would be secured. The “alternative corridor” would not be
possible without a settlement, hence the US interest in the peace talks and
Biden’s assurance that “Cyprus can be an even stronger partner (of the US) if
the next generation of Cypriots can grow up without the burden of conflict.”
When
we put all this together, the real significance of the Vice President’s visit
becomes apparent. Cyprus is at the centre of the US plans for the region which
would be used to counter Russia’s domination of the energy sector. There has to
be a settlement for Cyprus to be able to perform the regional role the
Americans envisage. But before all this happens we would have to make a choice,
which might not have been explicitly mentioned by Biden but is inevitable in
the very near future. Cyprus will have to choose between the US and Russia
because being strategic partners of both is impossible in the current world
climate. Biden’s visit, it could be said, was aimed at helping us make the
right decision.
Coffeeshop: We’re missing the
message. Give up on the Russians
The
Cyprus Mail’s satirical column Coffeeshop says that everyone is wondering what
the purpose of Biden’s visit was. There was no announcement about Famagusta or
any other confidence-building measures, as had been expected; nor was there any
suggestion of a US initiative with regard to the Cyprob. Had he come all the
way to Kyproulla, with 400 security people in tow just to take the piss out of
us? How else should we have interpreted his assertions that we were a “strategic
partner” of the US and his claim that “you are emerging as a leader in the
region and Cyprus is poised to become a key player in the Eastern
Mediterranean?”
The
strategic partnership kept coming up at the meeting at the presidential palace
between the two delegations, but our government seemed unable to grasp what
Biden and his lieutenants were actually hinting at. It raised mundane issues
such as the issuing of visas, the violation of our EEZ by the Turks and the
need to open Famagusta.
Biden’s
interest, according to our mole, was to get us on side because of the growing
rivalry between the US and Russia, after the events in the Ukraine. The Yanks
cannot see Kyproulla playing the important role they have assigned to her in
the energy field, if we carry on acting like a Russian satellite, slavishly
obeying Vladimir Putin’s diktats as was the case during the Tof’s reign of
incompetence.
What
Biden was diplomatically telling us was that we would have to choose camp. This
obviously did not register with our foreign minister Ioannis Kasoulides, who
naively said on Friday, relations with Russia had not been harmed in any way by
the enhanced Cyprus US relations.
“Russia
respects Cyprus’ right to exercise its foreign policy within the EU, where we
belong,” declared Kasoulides. It respects this right so much, that as soon as
Biden’s visit was announced it informed the Cyprus government that its deputy
foreign minister would be arriving on the island and would like a meeting with
the president.
Moscow,
in contrast to our slow-witted diplomats, has understood what the Yanks are
trying to do and will try to stop them. It has plenty of leverage thanks to the
Russian businesses operating in Kyproulla and if we refuse to play ball it
could put Kyproulla on the tax black-list, which our auditors, lawyers and
politicians have always dreaded.